Episode Archive

You can choose your own adventure — listen to a few or binge them all!

Favored or Forsaken

Favored Or Forsaken: Baylor, Newsboys, And Nick Jonas

Join Erin, Evan, and Jamie as we discuss Baylor’s current clash with the Baptists, Nick Jonas’s latest musical endeavor, and the massive lawsuit from the Newsboys. Along the way, we unpack our complicated history with charity orgs and dream up the ultimate pop and CCM collaborations.

Apple Spotify Overcast Pocket Casts Pandora

All Episodes

Episode

Favored or Forsaken: Baylor, Newsboys, and Nick Jonas

May 14, 2026

Join Erin, Evan, and Jamie as we discuss Baylor’s current clash with the Baptists, Nick Jonas’s latest musical endeavor, and the massive lawsuit from the…

Who the Hell are the Gideons?

May 7, 2026

In this episode, Erin and Evan are deep-diving the Gideons! You’ll learn about the traveling salesman roots of the organization, where the name comes from…

The Global South Church with Father Joash P. Thomas

April 30, 2026

In this very special episode, Erin sits down with Fr. Joash P. Thomas, a public theologian and author of The Justice of Jesus. They explore…

Instagram Heresy 2: Motherhood, Kristin Stewart, and The Hulk

April 23, 2026

Join Erin and Evan as they unpack listener-submitted memes, reels, and posts. Along the way, they develop a full theology of memes, debate whether Mary…

Favored or Forsaken: Women Shaping the Church, The Manosphere, and Post-Easter Roundup

April 16, 2026

It’s time for our monthly Favored or Forsaken! Join Erin, Evan, and Evan as we discuss awesome women who are shaping the church, what’s going…

Passed Over Snake Draft

April 9, 2026

Join Erin, Evan, and Jamie as we discuss biblical concepts or faith themes that have been ignored or overlooked. We’ll look at passed over Marys…

SWDGISS: Atonement Theories

April 2, 2026

In this latest Stuff We Didn’t Get in Sunday School Episode, Erin and Evan are discussing popular atonement theories and answering listener questions about things…

Easter Spectacles, Sunrise Services, and Easter Bunny Anatomy

March 26, 2026

Join Erin, Evan, and Jamie as we share our personal yeses that are definitely nos for everyone else plus plenty of cringe listener comments! You’ll…

Favored or Forsaken: The Great Controversy, Medically Assisted Suicide, and an Upcoming Bible-Based RPG

March 19, 2026

It’s time for our monthly Favored or Forsaken! We talk about The Great Controversy, share our varied thoughts on medically assisted suicide, and dig into…

How to Leave Christian Nationalism with Reverend Rob Schenck

March 12, 2026

The very reverent (or irreverent) Rob Schenck is joining Erin in this very special episode! Reverend Rob shares his transformative journey from a prominent evangelical…

Episode Playlists

We created playlists so you don’t have to dig through the archives to find your favorite episodes. Be still and binge!

View All Playlists